Some Wake County residents are pushing back against the WakeMed board’s decision to reject Dr. Mandy Cohen, who served as the state’s top health official during the COVID-19 pandemic and later served as director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, from its ranks.
”How could anyone argue that Dr. Mandy Cohen is not the single most qualified and best candidate to help guide our community hospital during a pivotal transition like the Atrium Health merger?” Khaleel Faheemud-Deen, a member of the advocacy group Men of Southeast Raleigh, asked Wake County commissioners on Monday.
Cohen submitted an application to Wake County commissioners to be considered for a spot on the WakeMed board as the hospital merges with Atrium Health, North Carolina’s largest hospital system. Commissioners, a majority of whom wanted Cohen to serve, sent her application to the WakeMed board, which denied her a seat without explanation, The News & Observer reported Friday.
On Monday, county commissioners reappointed five members currently serving on the hospital’s board, a condition of the merger agreement. All five voted in favor of the Atrium merger. Commissioners also named three new hospital board members.
But a handful of Wake County residents asked why commissioners had rolled over so easily when the hospital board rejected Cohen. Some wondered if Cohen’s rejection foreshadows diminishing local control of the hospital board.
Faheemud-Deen urged commissioners not to “rubber-stamp a compromised slate of appointees.”
Artis Watkins, the executive director of the State Employees Association of North Carolina, agreed.
“Dr. Cohen is someone who would speak not for the wealthy and connected who are represented quite well on that board right now, but for the regular people of Wake County,” Watkins said. “They matter. State employees matter. Retirees matter. Your own county employees matter.”
Commissioner Tara Waters, who along with Commissioner Vickie Adamson voted against the WakeMed-Atrium merger in September, cast the lone “no” vote on the slate of appointees. (Adamson was absent from Monday’s meeting.)
“[Cohen’s] leadership experience … represented the kind of expertise and credibility that I believe could help strengthen confidence in this process and the future of WakeMed,” Waters said.
She added that her vote wasn’t a knock against the eight appointees, who she thanked for volunteering to serve their community. Rather, she was concerned “about the structure of this process, the imbalance of authority, and whether we have done enough to ensure that the community has a meaningful voice in the future of an institution that means so much to Wake County.”
Other commissioners said the WakeMed board was within its rights to reject Cohen.
“I’m not happy with the decision that they made,” said Commissioner Susan Evans, “but I have to respect the process.”
The five reappointed members are Mary Nash Rusher, a retired lawyer; Keemia Hurst Shaw, a social worker; Margaret Bratton, a paralegal; Fred Anderson, the chairman of a large car dealership group; and Peter Scott, the president of a management consulting firm.
The newly appointed members are Cheryl Walker-McGill, Karen Burke, and Pablo Escobar. Walker-McGill and Burke are physicians with decades of experience in clinical and administrative settings, according to their applications. Escobar is a retired former financial officer for Kaiser Permanente, one of the largest health care systems in the country.
In their board applications, many of the eight appointees mentioned charity care and accountability to the community among their priorities for WakeMed.
“I believe the true measure of a healthcare institution’s success is not simply how much it grows, but how meaningfully that growth improves the lives of the people and communities it serves,” wrote Walker-McGill.
The merger agreement between WakeMed and Atrium, which Wake County signed off on in September, calls for a 14-member board: eight members who live in Wake County and are appointed by Wake County commissioners, and six members chosen by Atrium Health. Previously, commissioners appointed the entire board with input from its sitting members.
Under the agreement, two-thirds of the hospital’s board members must approve the county’s picks. That means Atrium’s appointees—who will join after the merger is approved by the Federal Trade Commission and the state Attorney General’s office—will effectively have veto power over the commissioners’ choices.

